From - Thu Jun 27 09:23:28 2002
Return-Path: <bagenal@boulder.Colorado.EDU>
Received: from schubert.obs-nice.fr (schubert.obs-nice.fr [192.54.174.60])
          by purcell.obs-nice.fr (8.12.3/jtpda-5.4) with ESMTP id g5OFwnlZ167534
          for <guillot@purcell.obs-nice.fr>; Mon, 24 Jun 2002 17:58:49 +0200 (CEST)
Received: from boulder.Colorado.EDU (boulder.Colorado.EDU [128.138.240.1])
          by schubert.obs-nice.fr (8.12.3/jtpda-5.4) with ESMTP id g5OFvGSs015267
          for <guillot@obs-nice.fr>; Mon, 24 Jun 2002 17:57:16 +0200 (MET DST)
Received: from lasp.colorado.edu (lasp.Colorado.EDU [128.138.137.141])
	by boulder.Colorado.EDU (8.10.1/8.10.1/UnixOps+Hesiod (Boulder)) with ESMTP id g5OFvEe18019;
	Mon, 24 Jun 2002 09:57:14 -0600 (MDT)
Received: from [128.138.141.17] (MacD39 [128.138.141.17])
	by lasp.colorado.edu (8.10.2+Sun/8.10.2) with ESMTP id g5OFvDv07107;
	Mon, 24 Jun 2002 09:57:13 -0600 (MDT)
Mime-Version: 1.0
X-Sender: bagenal@lasp.colorado.edu
Message-Id: <p0500190bb93cf1240a8c@[128.138.141.17]>
In-Reply-To: <3CCEB07D.3C8DDC5B@obs-nice.fr>
References: <3CC97936.2861E39C@obs-nice.fr>
 <p0500191db8ef5a678892@[128.138.141.17]> <3CCEB07D.3C8DDC5B@obs-nice.fr>
Date: Mon, 24 Jun 2002 09:57:12 -0600
To: Tristan Guillot <guillot@obs-nice.fr>
From: Fran Bagenal <bagenal@boulder.Colorado.EDU>
Subject: Ch 3 interiors chapter review
Cc: bagenal@colorado.edu, rose.hoag@lasp.colorado.edu
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" ; format="flowed"
Status: RO
X-Mozilla-Status: 8001
X-Mozilla-Status2: 00000000
X-UIDL: 3a4d141e00001aaa

Dear Tristan,
Here is a review of your chapter. It looks pretty good to me. I admit 
I am having difficulty contacting reviewers for this chapter - I'm 
not sure how many more reviews you will receive. In the meantime, 
here's something to get started on.
Fran


This is a very nicely presented review that concisely summarizes the
pertinent observations, experimental evidence, and theory related to
the interior structure of Jupiter.  For the most part it is very clear
and readable and could be published as is.  As a reviewer I have no
major comments, but I do have some more modest suggestions that I
believe could improve the readability and clarity of the text.  Although
this ground has been crossed before the authors are to be commended on
giving the material a fresh face and giving a fuller and more informative
treatment to some issues (particularly the magnetic field) than they
usually receive.

Comments (in order they are found in the text, not relative importance):

1) S. 3.2.2, third paragraph, "similarity is far more"   awkward

2) S. 3.2.3, second paragraph.  Since it is counter-intuitive that the
removal of helium to deeper layers makes the overlying layers denser
(presumably because a fraction of the He atoms are replaced by higher
Z material), this should be explained more fully.

3) third paragraph, It might be mentioned that the 5-um window probes
deeper in the planet than other places.

4) 3.2.4, fourth paragraph, last sentence, replace "obtained" with
"remotely measured" or something similar

5) fifth paragraph, the sudden appearance of "hot spot" is a bit incongrous,
perhaps this can be remedied along with (3)

6) 3.2.6, It might bear mentioning that part of the reason direct
measurements of oscillations are so difficult is the complex nature
of the atmosphere, see

Lederer, S.~M., Marley, M.~S., Mosser, B., Maillard, J.~P.,
Chanover, N.~J., \& Beebe, R.~F.\ 1995, Albedo features and Jovian
seismology, Icarus, 114, 269

7) 3.3.2, third paragraph, last sentence "an the low gas" should be
"and the low gas"

8) Figure 3.2.  This figure would be helped by some combination of
thicker lines, bigger labels, and use of color.  The other figures
are fine.

9) 3.4.1, after equation (4), first set of parens does not close

10) 3.4.1, last paragraph, strictly speaking condensed TiO (CaTiO3) is
not a silicate

11) 3.4.3, this section might be better titled "Inhibitors of convection"

12) Figure 3.5, I would suggest adding the possible location of the
radiative zone to the list of boxes

13) 3.5.2, third paragraph, it is not very clear what "more regular
solutions" means

14) 3.5.2 and figure 3.6, Perhaps the single biggest additions that I
would like to see are here.  It would be nice, if possible, to show
on Figure 3.6 or at least discuss more clearly which part of parameter
space is consistent with the Galileo observed atmospheric enrichment of
3x solar.  There are some comments that particular models are consistent with
this observation, but can more be said?  Does this rule out certain
classes of the models shown in the figure, or is it more of a shotgun
pattern on the figure?

I would also have to say that this figure has always left me a little
cold (it cleverly presents a lot of information, but it takes a while
to digest).  It would be nice to add a few points on this figure (e.g. ABCD)
and then have a corresponding table that lists the parameters associated
with the corresponding 3-layer model. I realize that this is fraught with
peril and that the unwary might simply turn to the table as the
final word on the subject, but I think it would also be very useful
to have a handy table that elucidates the current uncertainties in the
models.  This would in fact help to focus future discussion of the topic,
I believe.  One could write "Considering two extreme cases (Models C and
D of Guillot et al.) we find....". I expect it is a purposeful decision
by the authors to have no such table, but would ask them to reconsider.

15) 3.5.3, last paragraph "suggest" -> "suggests"

16) 3.6.1, third paragraph "fastened" -> "hastened"

17) 3.6.2, second paragraph, the contradiction with Pollack et al.
needs a bit more elucidation
-- 
___________________________________________________________________
Fran Bagenal
Professor of Astrophysical & Planetary Sciences
Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics
CB 392 Duane Physics D143
University of Colorado, Boulder CO 80309-0391
Tel: 303 492 2598
Fax: 303 492 6946
E-mail: bagenal@colorado.edu
___________________________________________________________________

