-------------------------------- TEST_1 : Analysis of the results -------------------------------- F. Mignard 05/12/05 -------------------------------- Report on the different running conditions for the frequency analysis of a signal giving the distance Earth to Sun in km as a function of time. The data is arranged in two columns with the time in days with origin at J2000 and the distance between the Earth and the Sun in km. There are 2001 records in each data set. The test illustrates the difference in the frequency recovery between regular and irregular sampling and how one experiment with the setting parameters to get the best results. This is a summary of the detailed outputs in spectra_d_sun_.... in the same directory. Distances Earth-Sun file : distance_sun_10.txt ------------------------------------------------- Step : 10 days nstep : 2000 centered at J2000 Nyquist freq : 0.05 cy/d (P = 20 days) :: line 3 : lunar month f = 0.03386 cy/d p : 29.530 days Frequency Period cos term sine term sigma(f)/f sigma(cos) sigma(sin) amplitude phase(deg) S/N 0 t^0 0.00000000E+00 1.49618801E+08 2.957E+01 1.496188E+08 0 t^1 0.00000000E+00 -3.82922843E-03 5.120E-03 -3.829228E-03 1 t^0 2.73777824E-03 3.65259679E+02 -2.49690175E+06 -1.07870877E+05 1.686E-07 4.199E+01 4.192E+01 2.499231E+06 177.5262522 1.20E+07 2 t^0 5.47553990E-03 1.82630392E+02 -2.08125551E+04 -1.79217828E+03 1.009E-05 4.187E+01 4.183E+01 2.088958E+04 175.0783759 9.97E+04 3 t^0 3.38632095E-02 2.95305736E+01 2.15520610E+03 4.07969378E+03 7.376E-06 4.182E+01 4.181E+01 4.613980E+03 297.8464384 2.27E+04 4 t^0 3.42518919E-03 2.91954676E+02 -2.24694865E+03 -7.15511503E+02 1.428E-04 4.187E+01 4.182E+01 2.358121E+03 162.3366020 1.16E+04 5 t^0 2.50465671E-03 3.99256312E+02 9.99362044E+02 -2.32277589E+03 1.823E-04 4.196E+01 4.194E+01 2.528638E+03 66.7204632 1.13E+04 6 t^0 5.01343622E-03 1.99463992E+02 9.18658829E+02 1.07845431E+03 1.626E-04 4.184E+01 4.186E+01 1.416685E+03 310.4253253 6.80E+03 Comments on the values and assessment : r/a = 1 +e^2/2 -e*cos(M) -e^2/2*cos(2M) + .... with 1 AU = 149 597 900 km expected found Constant term 149 618 750 149 618 800 1 yr 2 499 330 2 499 231 0.5 yr 20 880 20 890 the phases are also correct as the origin of time is J2000 when M = 357.529 deg. The period should be that of the anomalistic year 365.2596412 days and one gets 359.25968 +/- 0.00006 d Other lines : line 3 : Lunar month 4 : 2(V - E) 5 : E - J 6 : 2(E - J) Distances Earth-Sun file : distance_sun_20.txt ----------------------------------------------- Step : 20 days nstep : 2000 Nyquist freq : 0.02500 cy/d (P = 40 days) :: line 3 : lunar month ? f = 0.01613 cy/d ==> mirror line 2*nyquist - nu = 0.05-0.01613 = 0.03386 cy/d The regular sampling does not allow to recover the lunar frequency and adds a mirror line Frequency Period cos term sine term sigma(f)/f sigma(cos) sigma(sin) amplitude phase(deg) S/N 0 t^0 0.00000000E+00 1.49618792E+08 3.918E+01 1.496188E+08 0 t^1 0.00000000E+00 -4.61176040E-03 3.392E-03 -4.611760E-03 1 t^0 2.73777823E-03 3.65259680E+02 -2.49696330E+06 -1.07798689E+05 1.117E-07 5.545E+01 5.546E+01 2.499289E+06 177.5279665 7.83E+04 2 t^0 5.47555500E-03 1.82629889E+02 -2.07973337E+04 -1.80719702E+03 6.690E-06 5.540E+01 5.544E+01 2.087570E+04 175.0337230 2.33E+03 3 t^0 1.61368114E-02 6.19701113E+01 2.15569165E+03 -4.07999663E+03 1.026E-05 5.543E+01 5.540E+01 4.614475E+03 62.1499875 1.50E+03 4 t^0 2.50814197E-03 3.98701513E+02 8.63413265E+02 -2.32112147E+03 1.229E-04 5.545E+01 5.546E+01 2.476507E+03 69.5957514 6.90E+02 5 t^0 3.42514317E-03 2.91958598E+02 -2.26447524E+03 -6.70926798E+02 9.451E-05 5.540E+01 5.544E+01 2.361777E+03 163.4963092 6.65E+02 6 t^0 5.01414964E-03 1.99435612E+02 9.25751079E+02 1.03163883E+03 1.099E-04 5.544E+01 5.540E+01 1.386107E+03 311.9035228 5.24E+02 Distances Earth-Sun file : distance_sun_20_r.txt ------------------------------------------------- Step : 20 days on the average random sampling each step random and uniform between 10 and 30 days nstep : 2000 auto (.t.) or not (.f.) : T :: highest frequency determined by the program Last (highest) frequency analysed : 0.35536E-01 Line 3 is correct. Frequency Period cos term sine term sigma(f)/f sigma(cos) sigma(sin) amplitude phase(deg) S/N 0 t^0 0.00000000E+00 1.49618782E+08 3.913E+01 1.496188E+08 0 t^1 0.00000000E+00 -4.43529470E-03 3.415E-03 -4.435295E-03 1 t^0 2.73777804E-03 3.65259705E+02 1.42807537E+06 -2.05111469E+06 1.125E-07 5.573E+01 5.502E+01 2.499294E+06 55.1526837 7.83E+03 2 t^0 5.47555055E-03 1.82630037E+02 7.21800387E+03 1.95977210E+04 6.715E-06 5.515E+01 5.556E+01 2.088469E+04 290.2191725 1.65E+02 3 t^0 3.38632232E-02 2.95305616E+01 -3.34792645E+03 3.22515888E+03 4.933E-06 5.540E+01 5.552E+01 4.648684E+03 223.9299933 8.86E+01 4 t^0 2.50815642E-03 3.98699217E+02 1.81991408E+03 1.69268190E+03 1.230E-04 5.565E+01 5.512E+01 2.485409E+03 317.0744433 5.37E+01 5 t^0 3.42517936E-03 2.91955514E+02 2.29219955E+03 -4.39022647E+02 9.612E-05 5.541E+01 5.530E+01 2.333864E+03 10.8424952 7.22E+01 6 t^0 5.01458238E-03 1.99418401E+02 6.13376240E+01 -1.36982901E+03 1.118E-04 5.533E+01 5.536E+01 1.371202E+03 87.4361464 5.21E+01 The highest frequency analysed was determined by the program as flauto =.true., and it could have been not sufficient to reach the moon frequency. With irregular sampling one can use flauto = .false. and select an higher value for the upper frequency without aliasing. This is done here : Distances Earth-Sun Step : 20 days on the average random sampling each step random and uniform between 10 and 30 days nstep : 2000 auto (.t.) or not (.f.) : F T :: highest frequency set by the user Preset lower frequency : 0.1000E-03 Preset upper frequency : 0.5000E-01 Last (highest) frequency analysed : 0.49997E-01 *** Origin of time in the following solution : -0.124162784E+03 Frequency Period cos term sine term sigma(f)/f sigma(cos) sigma(sin) amplitude phase(deg) S/N 0 t^0 0.00000000E+00 1.49618782E+08 3.913E+01 1.496188E+08 0 t^1 0.00000000E+00 -4.43529500E-03 3.415E-03 -4.435295E-03 1 t^0 2.73777804E-03 3.65259705E+02 1.42807537E+06 -2.05111469E+06 1.125E-07 5.573E+01 5.502E+01 2.499294E+06 55.1526837 9.37E+03 2 t^0 5.47555055E-03 1.82630037E+02 7.21800386E+03 1.95977210E+04 6.715E-06 5.515E+01 5.556E+01 2.088469E+04 290.2191725 1.88E+02 3 t^0 3.38632232E-02 2.95305616E+01 -3.34792645E+03 3.22515888E+03 4.933E-06 5.540E+01 5.552E+01 4.648684E+03 223.9299932 9.17E+01 4 t^0 2.50815642E-03 3.98699217E+02 1.81991408E+03 1.69268190E+03 1.230E-04 5.565E+01 5.512E+01 2.485409E+03 317.0744432 5.70E+01 5 t^0 3.42517936E-03 2.91955514E+02 2.29219955E+03 -4.39022642E+02 9.612E-05 5.541E+01 5.530E+01 2.333864E+03 10.8424951 7.21E+01 6 t^0 5.01458239E-03 1.99418401E+02 6.13377637E+01 -1.36982900E+03 1.118E-04 5.533E+01 5.536E+01 1.371202E+03 87.4361406 5.70E+01 No line has been rejected from the spectral resolution test Execution time in seconds : 2.58 Same file with a solution with 14 lines (and a linear term in time for the 1 yr line). One should note the dynamics of 10^4 between the strongest and weakest lines. The line of 1455 days is 3V - 2E. *** Origin of time in the following solution : 0.000000000E+00 Frequency Period cos term sine term sigma(f)/f sigma(cos) sigma(sin) amplitude phase(deg) S/N 0 t^0 0.00000000E+00 1.49618798E+08 8.222E+00 1.496188E+08 0 t^1 0.00000000E+00 -2.93728174E-03 7.181E-04 -2.937282E-03 1 t^0 2.73774747E-03 3.65263784E+02 -2.49695695E+06 -1.07820129E+05 1.132E-05 1.712E+01 1.228E+01 2.499284E+06 177.5274692 9.33E+03 t^1 1.50485414E-01 4.93640520E-01 2.103E-02 4.861E-01 5.160686E-01 286.9537472 2 t^0 5.47555467E-03 1.82629900E+02 -2.08008278E+04 -1.80123785E+03 1.412E-06 1.165E+01 1.161E+01 2.087867E+04 175.0508450 1.94E+02 3 t^0 3.38632191E-02 2.95305652E+01 2.15031253E+03 4.08640167E+03 1.048E-06 1.175E+01 1.162E+01 4.617632E+03 297.7538719 1.04E+02 4 t^0 2.50689806E-03 3.98899348E+02 9.69943449E+02 -2.27816509E+03 2.814E-05 1.184E+01 1.184E+01 2.476051E+03 66.9378081 6.43E+01 5 t^0 3.42504529E-03 2.91966942E+02 -2.26000922E+03 -6.83810712E+02 1.998E-05 1.166E+01 1.161E+01 2.361194E+03 163.1657661 9.75E+01 6 t^0 5.01412967E-03 1.99436406E+02 9.18559476E+02 1.02025049E+03 2.363E-05 1.165E+01 1.168E+01 1.372830E+03 311.9975748 7.43E+01 7 t^0 1.71244395E-03 5.83960720E+02 -1.11155816E+02 8.05148120E+02 1.170E-04 1.168E+01 1.158E+01 8.127848E+02 262.1396404 5.10E+01 8 t^0 2.56472040E-03 3.89906050E+02 -6.05915753E+02 3.70811164E+02 9.559E-05 1.183E+01 1.181E+01 7.103765E+02 211.4659940 5.08E+01 9 t^0 2.27597960E-03 4.39371250E+02 4.98810268E+02 1.69476365E+02 1.362E-04 1.168E+01 1.165E+01 5.268149E+02 341.2342332 4.24E+01 10 t^0 2.41408986E-03 4.14234788E+02 4.17428581E+02 -2.91380660E+02 1.367E-04 1.171E+01 1.173E+01 5.090671E+02 34.9164723 4.68E+01 11 t^0 5.13699259E-03 1.94666428E+02 -1.59132730E+02 3.44390308E+02 8.337E-05 1.160E+01 1.172E+01 3.793783E+02 245.1997167 3.89E+01 12 t^0 6.86995386E-04 1.45561385E+03 2.83334128E+02 1.38036795E+02 7.461E-04 1.162E+01 1.164E+01 3.151704E+02 334.0252432 3.48E+01 13 t^0 4.78276469E-03 2.09084089E+02 9.27883228E+01 2.59052292E+02 1.228E-04 1.165E+01 1.164E+01 2.751686E+02 289.7066992 3.24E+01 14 t^0 8.21370359E-03 1.21747758E+02 -2.55398838E+02 -3.32570244E+01 7.615E-05 1.162E+01 1.163E+01 2.575550E+02 172.5809159 3.07E+01 No line has been rejected from the significance test No line has been rejected from the spectral resolution test Execution time in seconds : 6.36